Sports Cards > Baseball Cards > fleer > 1989 Fleer

Don Mattingly #258 1989 Fleer

Don Mattingly #258 Baseball Cards 1989 Fleer Prices

Useful Sites..

PSA $25 Off Code: PC25 Code: PC25

Fanatics

- In One Click
- With Details
+ Collection
+ Wishlist
Buy/Sell
Item Details
Show Historic Prices

Add this item to your collection.
Keep track of your collection value over time. Ok

Compare vs Other Items

Ungraded	Grade 7	Grade 8	Grade 9	Grade 9.5	PSA 10
$1.63 +$0.11	$1.00 $0.00	$1.00 $0.00	$9.99 $0.00	$20.00 $0.00	$27.99 $0.00	+
volume: 2 sales per week	volume: 1 sale per year	volume: 5 sales per year	volume: 5 sales per year	volume: 1 sale per year	volume: 1 sale per month	+

Grade 9	Grade 9.5	PSA 10
$9.99 $0.00	$20.00 $0.00	$27.99 $0.00
volume: 5 sales per year	volume: 1 sale per year	volume: 1 sale per month

Ungraded Sold Listings (29)

Grade 7 Sold Listings (4)

Grade 8 Sold Listings (11)

Grade 9 Sold Listings (19)

PSA 10 Sold Listings (30)

All Sold Listings

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-01-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 Baseball Card New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$1.99	Report It
2025-01-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	DON MATTINGLY 1989 FLEER NEW YORK YANKEES CARD #258 #258 [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2025-01-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$2.00	Report It
2025-01-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer Baseball Card #258 DON MATTINGLY Yankees Pack Fresh Mint [eBay]	$1.60	Report It
2025-01-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer Don Mattingly Baseball Card #258 Mint FREE SHIPPING #258 [eBay]	$1.25	Report It
2025-01-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$1.99	Report It
2025-01-07	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer DON MATTINGLY Baseball Card #258 New York Yankees MINT in toploader! #258 [eBay]	$1.75	Report It
2025-01-04	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	Don Mattingly 1989 Fleer # 258 New York Yankees (2 Cards) * NM - MINT or Better #110 [eBay]	$1.98	Report It
2025-01-03	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$1.59	Report It
2025-01-01	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$1.39	Report It
2024-12-31	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer New York Yankees Baseball Card #258 Don Mattingly [eBay]	$1.69	Report It
2024-12-29	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	Don Mattingly - 1989 Fleer - # 258 - Yankees [eBay]	$0.84	Report It
2024-12-27	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$1.00	Report It
2024-12-13	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	DON MATTINGLY - 1989 Fleer- #258 - Yankees - Comb. Shipping #258 [eBay]	$1.00	Report It
2024-12-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly Graded 8.5 NM/Mint+ #258 [eBay]	$7.95	Report It
2024-12-06	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$0.17	Report It
2024-12-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer - #258 Don Mattingly EXNM .I62 #258 [eBay]	$1.00	Report It
2024-11-23	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly #258 [eBay]	$1.29	Report It
2024-11-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$0.25	Report It
2024-11-08	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$0.55	Report It
2024-10-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$0.90	Report It
2024-10-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$1.50	Report It
2024-10-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$0.34	Report It
2024-10-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer - #258 Don Mattingly #258 [eBay]	$1.55	Report It
2024-10-17	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 B89 #258 [eBay]	$1.99	Report It
2024-10-04	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$0.25	Report It
2024-10-01	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer New York Yankees Baseball Card #258 Don Mattingly #258 [eBay]	$1.99	Report It
2024-09-29	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 NRMINT. #258 [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2024-09-27	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$0.30	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-01-09	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer - #258 Don Mattingly HOF PSA 7 NM - Fresh Slab #258 [eBay]	$4.25	Report It
2024-01-04	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer - Don Mattingly #258 - New York Yankees - HOF - PSA 7 #258 [eBay]	$3.99	Report It
2022-01-24		1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 New York Yankees PSA 7 NM #258 [eBay]	$6.94
2022-01-20		1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258, PSA 7, Sealed Set Break, NEW GRADE 2021 [eBay]	$7.99

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-12-12	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer # 258 Don Mattingly PSA 8 #258 [eBay]	$1.00	Report It
2024-07-19	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer MLB Card #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees MINT CGC 8 #258 [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2024-06-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258, New York Yankees, PSA 8, New Grade 2024 #258 [eBay]	$8.99	Report It
2024-02-25	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER DON MATTINGLY #258 PSA 8 NM-MT #258 [eBay]	$0.99	Report It
2024-01-05	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 PSA 8 NM-MT Yankees #258 [eBay]	$8.79	Report It
2023-12-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 PSA 8 #258 [eBay]	$4.20	Report It
2023-11-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 PSA 8 (59) Yankees [eBay]	$5.50	Report It
2023-05-23		1989 FLEER DON MATTINGLY #258 NEW YORK YANKEES PSA 8 NM-MT #258 [eBay]	$5.00	Report It
2023-05-01		1989 FLEER MLB BASEBALL DON MATTINGLY GRAED PSA 8 NM-MT CARD #258 N.Y. YANKEES [eBay]	$4.99	Report It
2023-03-02		1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 PSA 8 NM MINT #258 [eBay]	$10.00	Report It
2022-10-16		1989 Fleer DON MATTINGLY #258 PSA 8 NM MINT New York Yankees Marlins #258 [eBay]	$4.69

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-06-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9 B3982830-591 [eBay]	$9.99	Report It
2024-06-15	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9 B3982841-597 [eBay]	$9.99	Report It
2024-06-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9 B3982812-593 [eBay]	$9.99	Report It
2024-05-04	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer - #258 Don Mattingly-SGC9 #258 [eBay]	$1.75	Report It
2024-04-16	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 DON MATTINGLY PSA 9 MINT New York Yankees “Donnie Baseball” #258 [eBay]	$3.25	Report It
2024-04-02	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly PSA 9 MINT #258 [eBay]	$18.00	Report It
2024-02-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer # 258 Don Mattingly 4073 PSA 9 Mint Combined Shipping [eBay]	$8.50	Report It
2023-12-18	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer - #258 Don Mattingly, PSA 9 #258 [eBay]	$6.50	Report It
2023-09-17	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	PSA 9 MINT 1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 New York Yankees Card [eBay]	$24.99	Report It
2023-06-18		1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 PSA 9 MINT Yankees #258 [eBay]	$14.99	Report It
2022-09-28		1989 FLEER BASEBALL #258 DON MATTINGLY NEW YORK YANKEES PSA 9 MINT [eBay]	$20.50
2022-07-16		1989 FLEER BASEBALL #258 DON MATTINGLY NEW YORK YANKEES PSA 9 MINT [eBay]	$5.99
2022-04-26		1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees PSA 9 MINT [eBay]	$17.50
2022-04-24		1989 DON MATTINGLY FLEER #258 MINT PSA 9. #258 [eBay]	$11.50
2022-04-24		1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 PSA 9 New York Yankees MINT (11) S939 [eBay]	$9.50
2022-03-07		1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 Yankees PSA 9 MINT NEW SLAB #258 [eBay]	$23.95
2022-02-15		1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 Yankees PSA 9 MINT NEW SLAB #258 [eBay]	$23.95
2021-12-17		1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees HOF PSA 9 MINT 🔥📈🔥 #258 [eBay]	$20.00
2021-05-01		1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees PSA 9 MINT [eBay]	$5.50

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2024-04-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	CGC 9.5 MINT+ 1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 New York Yankees Card #258 [eBay]	$20.00	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2025-01-01	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B4154583-777 [eBay]	$24.99	Report It
2024-11-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B4062393-916 [eBay]	$24.99	Report It
2024-10-23	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B4021680-098 [eBay]	$27.99	Report It
2024-09-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly 💎 Gel Mint PSA 10 💎 New York Yankees #258 [eBay]	$36.00	Report It
2024-09-28	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B4021669-089 [eBay]	$27.99	Report It
2024-09-27	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 DON MATTINGLY FLEER PSA 10 GEM-MT NEW YORK YANKEES DODGERS PERFECT #258 RZC #258 [eBay]	$64.95	Report It
2024-09-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 [eBay]	$36.50	Report It
2024-09-21	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER 258 DON MATTINGLY PSA 10 GEM MINT #258 [eBay]	$20.55	Report It
2024-09-19	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B4021668-088 [eBay]	$27.99	Report It
2024-08-20	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B3982844-594 [eBay]	$27.99	Report It
2024-08-11	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B3982845-592 [eBay]	$27.99	Report It
2024-06-27	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B3974227-104 [eBay]	$30.99	Report It
2024-05-31	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B3935368-381 [eBay]	$32.99	Report It
2024-05-27	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer DON MATTINGLY #258 PSA 10 - PSA registry set break [eBay]	$26.00	Report It
2024-05-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B3934752-687 [eBay]	$32.99	Report It
2024-05-14	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees PSA 10 GEM MINT [eBay]	$32.00	Report It
2024-04-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 #258 [eBay]	$31.00	Report It
2024-03-29	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER DON MATTINGLY #258 PSA 10 GEM MINT #258 [eBay]	$73.00	Report It
2024-02-24	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer # 258 Don Mattingly 4072 PSA 10 Gem Mint Combined Shipping [eBay]	$29.88	Report It
2024-01-22	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B3818385-101 [eBay]	$35.00	Report It
2024-01-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees PSA 10 GEM MINT [eBay]	$60.00	Report It
2023-12-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees PSA 10 GEM MINT #258 [eBay]	$54.99	Report It
2023-11-26	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B3761468-590 [eBay]	$37.99	Report It
2023-11-15	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 B3761469-576 [eBay]	$37.99	Report It
2023-11-10	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 FLEER #258 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 [eBay]	$33.76	Report It
2023-10-20	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	PSA 10 GEM MINT 1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 New York Yankees Card [eBay]	$79.99	Report It
2023-10-07	Time Warp shows photos of completed sales. >Subscribe ($6/month) to see photos. OK	1989 Fleer Baseball DON MATTINGLY #258 PSA 10 GEM MINT [eBay]	$42.00	Report It
2023-06-11		DON MATTINGLY 1989 FLEER BASEBALL #258 YANKEES PSA 10 GEM MINT [eBay]	$59.99	Report It
2023-05-22		DON MATTINGLY 1989 FLEER BASEBALL #258 YANKEES PSA 10 GEM MINT [eBay]	$42.00	Report It
2023-05-19		DON MATTINGLY 1989 FLEER BASEBALL #258 YANKEES PSA 10, Freshly Graded! [eBay]	$40.97	Report It

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

No sales data for this card and grade

Any value shown for this card with this grade is an estimate based on sales we've found for other grades and the age of the card.
This estimate is based on the card being PSA or BGS graded. Grades from other companies could be worth much less.

No sales data for this card and grade

We earn a commission if you click eBay links and buy stuff.

Sale Date ▲ ▼	TW	Title ▲ ▼	▲ ▼ Price
2023-05-10		DON MATTINGLY PSA 6 1989 Fleer Don Mattingly #258 YANKEES! #258 [eBay]	$3.50	Report It
2022-09-08		1989 Fleer DON MATTINGLY #258 PSA 6 EX-MT #300 [eBay]	$7.99

See an incorrect/misclassified sale? Please click "report" to notify admin.

No sales data for this card and grade

Click tabs to see historic sales data.
Click on a listing to see full details. Ok

Don Mattingly #258 (1989 Fleer) Details

Is Rookie Card:	No
Genre:	Baseball Card
Publisher:	Fleer
Card Number:	#258
Print Run:	n/a
Notes:	none

ePID (eBay):	15055990907
PriceCharting ID:	1933563

Description:	none

More Photos: 1989 Fleer: Don Mattingly #258 | Baseball Cards

Main Image

Full Price Guide: Don Mattingly #258 (1989 Fleer)

Ungraded	$1.63
Grade 1	-
Grade 2	$1.00
Grade 3	$1.00
Grade 4	$1.00
Grade 5	$1.00
Grade 6	$1.00
Grade 7	$1.00
Grade 8	$1.00
Grade 9	$9.99
Grade 9.5	$20.00
SGC 10	$17.00
CGC 10	$36.00
PSA 10	$27.99
BGS 10	$36.00
BGS 10 Black	$65.00
CGC 10 Pristine	$65.00

All prices are the current market price.

Don Mattingly #258 (1989 Fleer | Baseball Cards) prices are based on the historic sales. The prices shown are calculated using our proprietary algorithm.
Historic sales data are completed sales with a buyer and a seller agreeing on a price. We do not factor unsold items into our prices.
Chart shows the price of Don Mattingly #258 at the end of each month going back as long as we have tracked the item.

Don Mattingly #258 Baseball Cards 1989 Fleer